A quick comparison of three seminal 9mm 2011 Options for consideration with a comparison table of the Full-Size 9mm Pistols – EAA Girsan Witness 2311 vs Springfield Prodigy vs Staccato P. We highlight two of which we offer with more information on their product pages.
Table of Contents
When it comes to serious performance and versatility, full-size 9mm pistols are hard to beat. Whether you’re upgrading your competition setup, seeking a dependable duty weapon, or simply craving a top-tier range gun, today’s market offers outstanding options. In this guide, we’ll dive deep into the best full-size 9mm pistols of 2025, featuring a side-by-side look at the EAA Girsan Witness 2311 vs Springfield Prodigy vs Staccato P. If you’re deciding between an affordable 2011 pistol or a high-end duty gun, this breakdown has you covered.
🔥 9mm Full-Size Pistol Comparison
| Feature | EAA Girsan Witness 2311 9mm Pistol | Springfield Prodigy 9mm | Staccato P 9mm |
| Caliber | 9mm | 9mm | 9mm |
| Capacity | 20+1 | 17+1 / 20+1 | 17+1 / 20+1 |
| Barrel Length | 5″ | 4.25″ or 5″ | 4.4″ |
| Frame Material | Steel | Forged Steel | Aluminum/Steel Hybrid |
| Grip | Polymer | Polymer | Polymer |
| Sights | Adjustable | Fiber Optic Front / U-Notch Rear | Dawson Precision |
| Optics Ready | No | Yes | Yes |
| Weight | 25.6 oz | 32.5 oz | 33 oz |
| Safety | Ambidextrous | Ambidextrous | Ambidextrous |
| Action | Single Action | Single Action | Single Action |
| Included Accessories | 3 Magazines, Tactical Case | 2 Magazines | 2 Magazines |
| Price Range | ~$999 | ~$1,499 | ~$2,199 |
Quick Takeaways:
- The EAA Girsan Witness 2311 9mm Pistol shines for shooters looking for an affordable 2011 pistol that still delivers full-size performance. Its steel frame and 20+1 capacity offer incredible value under $1,000.
- The Springfield Prodigy 9mm steps up the game with an optics-ready slide and premium sights, making it a strong contender for competition or defensive use. A smart choice in the mid-tier price range.
- The Staccato P 9mm continues to dominate among duty-grade pistols. With a hybrid aluminum/steel frame and hand-fitted parts, it justifies its premium cost for those who demand perfection.
EAA Girsan Witness 2311 9mm Pistol
If you’re looking for serious performance without breaking the bank, the EAA Girsan Witness 2311 9mm Pistol deserves a closer look. Offering a modern twist on the classic 1911 platform, the Witness 2311 brings full-size firepower, premium features, and everyday reliability to the table — making it one of the best full-size 9mm pistols of 2025.
The Witness 2311 features a 5-inch carbon steel barrel, an ambidextrous safety, and adjustable sights for precision and control. Its rugged silver steel frame pairs with a textured black polymer grip to offer both durability and comfort, whether you’re training, competing, or defending.
With a 20+1 capacity and single-action trigger pull, this pistol delivers a crisp, clean break shot after shot. Plus, it comes ready with three 20-round magazines and a hard tactical case for secure storage and transport.
We currently have the EAA Girsan Witness 2311 9mm Pistol — along with several other iterations — available for sale. Whether you’re after a tactical-ready version or a classic configuration, we’ve got you covered with options to match your style and needs.
Key Features:
Size: Full Size
Caliber: 9mm
Barrel Length: 5″
Capacity: 20+1
Frame Material: Steel (Silver Finish)
Grip: Black Polymer
Action: Single Action
Sights: Adjustable
Safety: Ambidextrous
Weight: 25.6 oz.
Includes: 3 Magazines and Hard Tactical Case
Springfield Prodigy Ultimate Tactical Bundle
If you’re leaning toward the Springfield Prodigy 9mm, there’s a fully loaded option that takes tactical performance to the next level — the Ultimate Tactical Bundle. This exclusive kit bundles the Springfield Prodigy 1911 DS Coyote Brown, Steiner MPS Micro Pistol Sight, and SureFire X300 Turbo Weaponlight into one unbeatable package.
Step into the future of tactical excellence with a setup built for professionals and serious shooters alike.
Bundle Includes:
- Springfield Prodigy 1911 DS:
- Commander-sized 9mm with a 4.25″ bull barrel.
- Coyote Brown polymer grip for standout comfort and style.
- Optics-ready slide, fiber optic front sight, beavertail safety, and two 10-round double-stack magazines.
- Steiner MPS Micro Pistol Sight:
- 3.3 MOA red dot.
- Waterproof, fog-proof, and night vision compatible.
- Lightweight and durable with adjustable brightness settings.
- SureFire X300 Turbo Weaponlight:
- 66,000 candela and 650 lumens for maximum visibility.
- Rugged tan anodized finish and Rail-Lock mounting system for universal fit.
Why Choose the Ultimate Tactical Bundle?
This carefully curated kit combines innovation and craftsmanship into a complete tactical solution. Whether you’re dominating competition, training for duty, or simply upgrading your EDC setup, the Ultimate Tactical Bundle delivers precision, durability, and performance you can rely on.
Whether you’re comparing the EAA Girsan Witness 2311 vs Springfield Prodigy or considering the best 9mm 1911-style pistols available, there’s a perfect option for every shooter.
Conclusion
Choosing the right full-size 9mm pistol comes down to balancing your budget, needs, and preferences. The EAA Girsan Witness 2311 9mm Pistol stands out as the best value pick, giving shooters an accessible entry point into the world of double-stack 2011 pistols. Meanwhile, the Springfield Prodigy 9mm brings competition-ready features without the hefty price tag of a Staccato. For those chasing elite-level performance, the Staccato P 9mm remains the benchmark. Whether you’re searching for the best full-size 9mm pistols of 2025 or just comparing affordable 2011 pistols, this side-by-side look helps you make an informed decision.
